Shemini - Doing the Right Thing the Right Way (From last year 2024)

 

The beginning of Parashat Shemini tells us of the first day that Aharon and his sons served as Kohanim. 

 

Hashem commanded that several special sacrifices be offered in honor of this day, one of which was an עגל – a calf – which Aharon was to bring as a sin-offering.  The commentaries explain that Aharon was required to sacrifice an עגל to atone for his role in חטא העגל – the sin of the golden calf.  As we know, it was Aharon who collected gold from the people and turned it into the image of a calf, which the people worshipped.  Aharon needed כפרה (atonement) for this act, and so he was required to bring an עגל as a sacrifice.

 

This raises the question regarding Aharon's role in the story of חטא העגל.  Clearly, Aharon was a righteous man who would never worship an idol or encourage others to worship an idol.  There is no question that his intentions in this incident were pure.  According to some commentators, Aharon saw that the people were insistent on making an idol, and so he went along with the plan to delay the process, hoping that Moshe would return from the top of Mount Sinai in the interim.  Nevertheless, despite his good intentions, his actions resulted in a grave חילול ה', as the nation sinned by worshipping the idol that he created.  Therefore, although his intentions were pure, he was held accountable for the way he went about it, which yielded disastrous results.

 

The simple lesson that this incident shows us is that good intentions are not sufficient.  Even when we truly want to do the right thing, we need to go about it wisely.  We need to think carefully about how to carry out our intentions in the most appropriate and effective manner.

 

Just to give one example, I am sure most if not all of us have had the experience of being at a Shabbat table or social function when people start talking gossip or lashon ha'ra, and there's somebody present who, rightfully, wants no part in this forbidden conversation.  Sometimes, the person simply remains quiet and does not participate.  But sometimes the person chooses the less intelligent approach of condescendingly criticizing the people, telling them, "Oh, you talk about other people?  You talk lashon ha'ra?  I don't talk this way!"  His intentions are pure, but he goes about it the totally wrong way, making everyone at the table uncomfortable and upset.  This is neither helpful nor constructive.

 

Another example is the well-intentioned but very harmful comments that relatives sometimes make when a young man or woman starts becoming more religiously observant.  Almost invariably, there is an aunt or uncle who says something to the effect of, "What's wrong?  We're not religious enough for you?"  "You're wearing only long skirts now – how will you get married?"  "Oh, so you got brainwashed?"  "You're going to yeshiva – how do you expect to make a living?"

 

In some cases, the concern is legitimate.  It is understandable that family members might be worried about a young person making drastic changes that perhaps they are not prepared for, or decisions that will impact their future in ways that they might not realize.  The intentions might very well be pure – but these comments are very destructive.  So many young people have told me that the greatest impediment to spiritual growth that they've encountered is the fear of these comments by family members.

 

Here's an example of a well-intentioned comment made in the proper way.

 

I once received a phone call from somebody I never met, who told me that he listens to my classes online.  He told me how much he appreciates them and how much he gains from them.  He then mentioned to me that he watched a short video message that I had made a couple of days earlier, and that he liked it very much – but there was one thing I said which he thought was not appropriate.  And he politely explained to me why he felt that way.

 

I told him how much I appreciated and welcomed his feedback, and especially how he expressed his criticism so respectfully.

 

This is how it is done. 

 

If we are legitimately concerned about something and feel that a comment is in order, we need to go about it the right way.  The fact that our intentions are sincere does not mean that we can say it however we want.  The fact that our concern is legitimate does not make everything we say or do legitimate.  Even the great Aharon Ha'kohen needed to atone for doing the right thing, since it was not done in the right way.

 

Let's try to be smart, and not just right, and do the right thing in the right way.  Our input is often valuable and necessary – but only if we ensure to say it the right way, with respect, with love, with warmth, and with friendship, showing our genuine concern. - Rabbi Joey Haber

​

https://itorah.com/weekly-inspire/doing-the-right-thing-the-right-way-from-last-year-2024/15/29603